Essay Questions for Hound of the Baskervilles

Explain deduction. How is it used by the characters in the novel? Why is it so necessary for Holmes to see only the facts and to never actually theorize? Is this a realistic approach to unraveling mysteries? Why or why not?

Explain the themes of reality and superstition as they relate to this novel. Take into account the story of the Baskerville hound and how different people react to the events around them.

How is the moor an active character in this novel? What are characteristics of the moor? Is it just as important as Holmes or Stapleton? Why or why not?

What is the effect and purpose of Watson’s narration?

Discuss the relationship between Holmes and Watson.

In a well-crafted detective story, nothing is wasted; each scene adds suspense and clues to the hunt for “whodunnit.” Explain how Doyle creates a tightly written narrative to accomplish this. Include specific examples.

Compare and contrast the protagonist and antagonist in this story, Holmes and Stapleton.